3 year driving study shows road danger caused by unsafe manoeuvres

Rule 126 of the Highway Code makes it clear enough. It is a legal requirement for drivers to maintain a safe distance – or ‘headway’ – between themselves and the car in front – usually equating to a minimum ‘two second gap’. Failure to do so is a major contributor to road accidents in the UK, particularly in wet and icy conditions when stopping distances at least double.

But evidence from the analysis of three years of driving data completed as part of the MOVE_UK study has revealed that a worrying number of UK drivers fail to keep a reasonable gap between the cars in front and behind when ‘cutting in’ or changing lanes. This behaviour results in drivers having insufficient time available when it comes to braking to avoid potential collisions.

MOVE_UK was a three-year study which monitored driving behaviour in and around London’s Royal Borough of Greenwich. As the data partner on the project, leading telematics company The Floow analysed more that 8,500 hours and 100,000 miles of driving, equivalent to more than 60-year’s worth of driving experience.

The results were alarming:

  • Just over 20% of drivers were prone to cutting in between cars and were leaving less than a second between them and the car in front. This left very little reaction time, particularly for the car they have cut in front of.
  • One average, drivers cutting in at 25kmph or above do so left just a 1.35 second gap between them and the car behind them, meaning most drivers were not adhering to the guidance provided in the Highway Code.
  • It is typically those drivers who are leaving a safe gap between them and the car in front who become the victims of ‘cutting in’ because more dangerous drivers see this as an opportunity to push in.
  • At lower speeds this is not so much of a problem: almost a third (29%) of cut-ins happened at speeds of less than 19mph don’t require any braking or removal of the driver’s foot off the accelerator pedal. At higher speeds, 96% of the time drivers feel the need to react by either removal of their foot from the accelerator pedal or by applying the brake. Not only this, but the proportion of cut-ins requiring the driver to apply the brakes more than doubles (from 17% to more than 35%)
  • In wet weather, stopping distances roughly double and increase by as much as 10x in ice or snowy compared to dry conditions. The Floow’s research suggests most drivers do not allow for this. When windscreen wipers are active and a vehicle is moving faster than 12mph, the position of vehicles in front only increases by an average of two metres, which does not equate to a further two seconds of travel time, as the Highway Code recommends

The Floow’s data paints a starker picture than the UK Government’s statistics* which suggest that the majority (74%) of cars and Light Commercial Vehicles, and 66% of motorcycles, travelling on motorways left the recommended two-second gap between themselves and other vehicles.

Dr Sam Chapman, Chief Innovation Officer of The Floow commented: “By its own admission, DfT’s data comes from a very small sample size, so the MOVE_UK study is one of the most extensive ever completed to illustrate this problem. Adhering to the Highway Code isn’t optional. It’s a legal requirement to maintain a safe distance between yourself and other vehicles and the guidance on this is ‘the two second rule’. In fact, by driving at higher speeds you’d need more than two seconds to stop safely and avoid a collision.”

“Because cutting in dangerously close to the car in front is rarely enforced as an offence, many drivers have developed some very bad habits. Though UK accident statistics are not available for this behaviour as a specific cause of collisions, the MOVE_UK findings would suggest that dangerous manoeuvres and tailgating has reached epidemic proportions in the UK. And without time to break safely, accidents will happen.”

In order to tackle the problem, The Floow is calling for more awareness and vigorous enforcement against dangerous tailgators, supported by new regulations to enforce the use of connected car sensors that are able to detect this type of dangerous behaviour.

Dr Chapman added: “Technology that’s included in most new vehicles includes camera or radar sensors which are able to detect the distance in front and in some cases also behind a vehicle. Legislation that comes into force as early as next year will require every new vehicle in the EU to enable technology to accurately judge distances between forward vehicles. Dashcams can also do this. Importantly, drivers need to start taking control and adhering to the rules that have been in place since the 1970s. You’d fail your driving test if you cut in without leaving a safe gap. Our research demonstrates that drivers need to respect safe distances throughout their driving years – not just when they’re taking their test. Awareness campaigns, such as the Highways Agency ‘Space Invaders’ campaign, focus on surfacing the issue of tailgating and dangerous cutting in, but more must be done to draw attention to the problem.”

Advice for Drivers on Assessing Gaps and Stopping Distances 

Drivers are advised to think about stopping distances as thinking distance (i.e. your reaction time) plus braking distance (i.e. the time it would take to bring your vehicle to a stop). The faster a car is travelling, the longer it takes to stop, even if your car is equipped with features like ABS. Travelling at 40mph vs 30mph adds an extra 13 metres (more than three car lengths) to the distance it takes to come to a stop. When you are preparing to cut in to a gap between two vehicles, pause to think about the gap you will leave ahead and behind your car; it may not be possible for the car behind to brake safely and avoid colliding with you.

Sometimes it is difficult to assess the gap between you and another vehicle. You can estimate this by looking at a roadside object and counting the seconds between the vehicle in front passing it and you passing it.

Comments are closed.