Fleet Manager News And Tools

The Whole Life Cost Calculator - FleetPoint

Racking up 12 points doesn’t always signal a driving ban…but why?

By Kyle Lindsay
Wednesday, March 12, 2014 - 16:29

Comments (1)
Natali-Farrell-Just-Motor-Law

EXPERT: Natali Farrell, of Just Motor Law

In our latest Expert Blog, Natali Farrell, of Just Motor Law, explains how some drivers are still legally on the road despite having more than 12 points on their licence…

Clocking up 12 penalty points through speeding and other motoring offences usually means a minimum six-month driving ban.

According to latest figures released by the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency (DVLA) courts are showing leniency towards thousands of motorists who rely on their driving licence for their living such as sales representatives, rural workers, long distance commuters or HGV drivers, taxi drivers and couriers.

In November 2013 there were 7,293 UK drivers with 12 points or more who avoided what would otherwise have been a six-month disqualification – 84% were male drivers.

A 43-year-old man from south Liverpool is still permitted to drive despite clocking up 45 penalty points – almost four times the usual driving ban threshold.

The second highest tally is 36 points by a 58-year-old male driver from Warrington.

The data reveals 2,317 motorists have even more points than the traditional ‘automatic ban’ threshold, including 1,183 on 15 points or more.

Analysis reveals that 1,183 motorists with a valid licence have 15 points or more, and 18 motorists with a valid licence have 25 points or more.

The vast majority of the exceptions are on the 12-point limit – 4,976 in total – indicating that magistrates are being swayed by a defendant’s solicitor arguing that disqualification would cause exceptional hardship.

Magistrates can use discretion to not enforce driving disqualification if it will cause exceptional hardship.

Losing your job and potentially penalising family members as a result fits into this category.

Other examples might be a child being deprived of contact with a divorced parent, a disabled or infirm dependent who requires regular transport or a business owner or employer who will suffer disproportionate additional expense from having to pay for extra staff.

In some circumstances, a court will not impose a ban if a business will be significantly affected by a key member of staff being banned.

Simply being inconvenienced by having to get a bus to work or walking the kids to school, however, probably would not persuade a magistrate to make an exception.

Some critics say solicitors are exploiting a ‘loophole’ – but this is not the case.

We are not bending or abusing the law, we are using it in a perfectly properly way in the best interest of clients.

The driver is not ‘getting off’ with breaking the law, they are being dealt with in a different but fair way.

Of course, those that depend on their driving licence to earn a living need to take extra care to protect their licences, rather than rely on either the expertise of motor law specialists or the discretion of magistrates.

Related Stories

Comments

The comments are closed.

  • Moira Benson says...March 11, 2014 (19:53)

    So how can we encourage drivers who avoid a ban to improve their driving ability? Improving their skills would make the roads safer for everyone, including the driver, their children, parents, work colleagues and neighbours.