Only half of cars claiming to take three child car seats can fit them in

Tuesday, March 27, 2018 - 08:30
Comments off

Only half of the cars claiming to accommodate three child car seats at once can actually fit them in, according to new research by What Car?.

One in seven families in the EU (13%) have three or more children and, in the UK, 180,000 families have a third or fourth child every year.

By law, children must use car seats – whether secured by seatbelts or Isofix brackets – until they are 12-years-old or 135cm tall, meaning that the size and type of child car seats used for three children can vary considerably in size and style.

Despite being the fastest-growing family car sector in the UK, only one of the eight SUVs tested by What Car? – the Audi Q7 – was able to fit three child car seats across a single row of seats. Four of the SUVs tested couldn’t fit in three seats at once in any configuration.

The MPV category proved to be the best performer, with four of the six seven-seat cars tested able to accommodate three car seats across the middle row.

According to the new What Car? new car buying marketplace, the best deals on MPVs include a £21,799 price tag for a Seat Alhambra 1.4 TSI S and £19,590 for a Citroen Grand C4 Picasso 1.2 PureTech. Discounts on the site run as high as 26.7% on a Citroen Grand C4 Picasso and 22.1% on a Volkswagen Touran.

A hatchback and an estate with three Isofix points across their second seating row were also tested – neither were able to fit in three car seats side-by-side.

What Car? tested 16 of the best-selling cars in the UK and used the same three children – aged seven, four and 11 months – in every car; the youngest was in a Maxi-Cosi Pebble infant seat secured by the seat belt, while the older two were in Britax Romer Kidfix II seats with Isofix points.

Table showing What Car? child car seat fitting results

Sector Car Can fit three across single row Can fit three across two rows Can fit only two child car seats
SUV Audi Q7 Yes Yes No
SUV BMW X5 No Yes No
SUV Honda CR-V No No Yes
SUV Land Rover Discovery No Yes No
SUV Nissan X-Trail No No Yes
SUV Peugeot 5008 No No Yes
SUV Skoda Kodiaq No No Yes
SUV Volvo XC90 No Yes No
MPV Renault Grand Scenic No No Yes
MPV Vauxhall Zafira Tourer Yes Yes (but no Isofix points) No
MPV Citroen Grand C4 Spacetourer Yes Yes (but no Isofix points) No
MPV Ford S-Max No No Yes
MPV SEAT Alhambra Yes Yes No
MPV VW Touran Yes No No
Hatchback Audi A5 Sportback No No Yes
Estate Skoda Superb No No Yes


What Car? consumer editor Claire Evans, who conducted the research, said: “If you have a larger family, picking a car with seven seats might seem like a good solution, but it doesn’t guarantee a second row of seats wide enough to accommodate three child seats. And the rearmost row of seats in a seven-seater might not be a safe or practical place to position a child.

“Size doesn’t always equal practicality – even some of the biggest SUVs can only accommodate two child seats.

“Our research only shows one possible scenario in terms of the combination of child ages and car seat styles, but it highlights the need for parents to check that their child seats will fit properly into a car before buying it.”

Comments are closed.